Saturday, January 19, 2008

Cnet Vs. Jana Partners

In "A Loophole Lets a Foot in the Door" (Jan. 15), the New York Times' Andrew Ross Sorkin describes how CNET chief executive Neil Ashe had an hour-long conversation with activist investors at Jana Partners. According to the column, Ashe was then surprised when Jana and its group launched a proxy contest to take over the board. "They indicated to us that they were a long-only deep-value hedge fund," Ashe says, according to Sorkin. "I spent an hour with them on the phone answering questions about our business." Then, he adds: "We didn't hear anything from them again."
Sorkin uses this anecdote to explain how activist fund managers use "complex swap agreements with investment banks" to get around disclosure rules and launch surprise attacks. Is this the whole story, however? Maybe not. Regulatory filings disclose that prior to Sorkin's column, Jana Partners and its group held talks with CNET officials indicating that their activist campaign really should not have been any surprise to Ashe and probably wasn't.
In a 13D filing disclosed Jan 7, a week before Sorkin's column, Jana reported that representatives had held several calls with CNET through October, at least one of which was to discuss proposals for improving operations. The filing also says that Spark Management Partners LLC's Santo Politi, a venture capitalist and member of the Jana group, met on Dec. 6 with CNET chairman Jarl Mohn to inform him of the investment by the group, "to discuss proposals for improving the operating performance" and to request a follow-up meeting with independent board members; Ashe rejected the latter. "In a subsequent conversation, Mohn informed Politi that any discussions with members of the board would need to be coordinated by Ashe," the filing said.
Soon after, on Dec. 28, Jana delivered notice to CNET that it planned to nominate directors. These conversations demonstrate that Jana and its group actually had talks with CNET officials and aired their proposals. They also suggest that Jana didn't think everything was fine with the business. Ashe's decision to reject a meeting between CNET independent board members and the Jana group also shows that the situation wasn't exactly "friendly."
And let's get real. We're talking about Jana Partners here, a major activist hedge fund that regularly launches campaigns, not some obscure fund from under a rock. Sorkin gives the impression that Ashe was "surprised" because Jana had talked about becoming a "friendly, long-term shareholder." Any IR official or corporate executive with a heartbeat would know that Jana will launch an activist campaign if it doesn't get its way.
The issue of swaps is a matter for continuing debate, but one thing is clear from the filings: Ashe and his team were either not surprised, or shouldn't have been. - Ron Orol

Thursday, January 17, 2008

CtW calls out Merrill Lynch directors

An organization that advises pensions for unions belonging to the Change to Win labor group has a new target: Merrill Lynch & Co.

The pension fund, CtW Investment Group, is calling on Merrill Lynch directors to "describe what they did to protect shareholders from excessive mortgage-related risk over the past two years."
The fund said in a statement that it plans to launch a "just vote no" campaign against Merrill Lynch's nomination committee chairwoman, should the investment bank not provide a thoughtful response to its question. (CtW would have preferred to consider urging investors to oppose members of the finance committee, but none of these members are up for election this year.)
The investment fund earlier this week took similar actions against five directors at Citigroup Inc., another bank besieged with mortgage-related problems.
Both Citigroup and Merrill Lynch have recently been the recipients of massive cash infusions (read: bailouts) from controversial state-controlled sovereign wealth funds. In December, Temasek Holdings Pte. Ltd. took a $4.4 billion minority stake in Merrill Lynch. Abu Dhabi Investment Authority reported a $7.5 billion minority stake investment in Citigroup in November. - Ron Orol

Ron Orol is a Washington-based reporter for The Deal and author of Extreme Value Hedging: How Activist Hedge Fund Managers Are Taking on the World.

Tuesday, January 15, 2008

Luby's Wins Ramius Fight, with a caveat

A battle for the future of Luby's Inc. is finally over and the cafeteria operator's management came out on top, with a small caveat.

After agreeing to a condition, Luby’s management-backed director candidates at a Tuesday annual meeting beat out nominees put forward by dissident activist hedge fund Ramius Capital Group LLC.

The activist investor group launched a proxy contest on Oct. 17 to nominate four director candidates to Luby's board at the company's annual meeting, which took place today, Jan. 15. But their success can be attributed, in part, to a decision by Luby’s largest shareholders and the operators of the business, Chris and his brother Harris Pappas, to support a measure de-staggering the 10-person board.

The dissident investors were disappointed but noted that a majority of outside investors, not including shares owned by the Pappas family, appears to have voted to back their candidates. “Although we are disappointed that our nominees were not elected to the board of Luby’s, we believe the independent shareholders of Luby's have sent a strong message,” said Ramius partner Jeffrey C. Smith in a statement. “The preliminary indications show that a majority of the independent shareholders of Luby’s voted in favor of changes to the composition of the Luby’s board. “If you exclude the Pappases’ share ownership above the 15% poison pill threshold from the vote, it appears that a majority of shares voting would have supported change to the Luby’s board of directors.”

Luby's is an Houston, Texas-based operator of 130 cafeteria-style restaurants in Texas.
A key battle focused on the capabilities of each slate’s candidates and whether the Pappas brothers should have been permitted to have an exemption from Luby's poison pill, allowing them to own up to 28% of the company's shares, instead of the 15% allowed for other shareholders.
The restaurant chain on Jan. 2 issued a proxy to investors lashing out at Ramius' nominees, criticizing them for their limited experience in the restaurant industry or how their background has "little relevance to Luby's from-scratch cooking and casual dining." One nominee, Luby's wrote, is a Ramius director "for hire," has no restaurant industry experience and was recently rejected by shareholders of another publicly traded company.
The activists have taken issue with the company's granting Christopher Pappas, Luby's president, and Harris Pappas, his brother, an exemption from Luby's poison pill. While the Pappas brothers argue that increasing their personal financial stake in the company demonstrates their commitment to making sure the company's share price improves, Ramius is concerned that the greater ownership will mean more votes for management-backed directors (and less for them) at the contentious meeting. Ramius has also criticized how, in addition to Luby's, the Pappas brothers operate a private business, which means they have less time to focus on the publicly held Luby's.
Proxy Governance, a shareholder advisory service, recommended that investors vote for three of the four candidates on the Ramius slate. -- Ron Orol

Monday, January 14, 2008

Resurgence vs. SunLink

Message from health care company Resurgence Health Group LLC to SunLink Helath Systems Inc.: the diagnosis is not good and its time to sell.

SunLink Health Systems, the Atlanta-based operator of seven community hospitals in Alabama, Georgia and Mississippi, is being pressured by shareholders that includes Resurgence Health Group to respond to a takeover offer the group had made in November.

According to a Securities and Exchange Commission filing on Monday, a shareholder group including activist investor, Berggruen Holdings North America and Resurgence Health Group, want SunLink to respond to its $7.50 a share bid to take over the company. Resurgence and its group of investors, which own 9.4% of the hospital operator, had originally made the offer to buy SunLink in November.

The group on Jan. 11 sent a letter to Howard Turner, special counsel to the special committee of SunLink’s board, seeking a response. The group said it was disappointed that SunLink did not respond to their offer by Dec. 7. Subsequently they sent another letter, according to the filing. “Our client is frustrated with the Board’s inaction with respect to the Offer and believes that such inaction evidences management’s desire to remain entrenched at the expense of SunLink’s shareholders,” Resurgence Health wrote in the letter.

Last year, according to the filing, Berggruen Holding teamed up with Resurgence and agreed to provide the financing to enable Resurgence to make the bid. The bidders also complained about SunLink’s board, noting “close personal relationships” between management and certain directors and questioning whether they are looking out for shareholder interests.

“We urge you to act not in your own self-interests or in a manner beholden to management, but instead, in the best interests of all of your shareholders by contacting us promptly and meeting with us as soon as possible,” the letter said. SunLink has a $46 million stock market capitalization. - Ron Orol

Friday, January 11, 2008

Activst Vs. Broadcasting Inc.

Social video entertainment and networking over the Internet isn’t working so well for Broadcaster Inc., a Chatsworth, Calif.-based company.

At least that’s what activist hedge fund Baytree Capital Associates LLC believes. According to letter attached to an activist Securities and Exchange Commission filing on Friday, Baytree Capital director Michael Gardner believes the company is in a “dire situation” and he charged that Broadcaster has “failed to adhere” to board directives. “The board identified one specific merger candidate with which it instructed management to execute a letter of intent,” Gardner wrote. “Management executed the letter of intent but cancelled it the following day without any explanation or notice to the board.”

Gardner also charged in the SEC filing that Broadcaster’s board directed management to cut employees from 50 to 12, but that management did not “terminate” the employees. The letter was addressed to Broadcaster Chief Operating Officer Nolan Quan. The $8 million stock market capitalization company operates broadcaster.com, an Internet entertainment network.-- Ron Orol

Activists Move a Little Closer to Change At A. Schulman

Ramius Capital Group LLC on Thursday succeeded at getting two candidates elected to the board of A. Schulman Inc., a $566 million stock market capitalization paint and plastics company that the New York-based hedge fund has been pressing to complete a strategic review that could result in a sale of the business.
The winning candidates backed by the dissident investor group, Michael Caporale and Lee Meyer, filled seats vacated by James Karman and Joseph Gingo. The latter is A. Schulman's chief executive. The dissidents had hoped to force the Akron, Ohio, company to auction to itself or consider other changes to improve stagnating shareholder value. In various government filings, the activist investors have raised concerns about the company's performance and had originally nominated four candidates for board nomination but later reduced the number to a pair they believed were experts in related areas.
Although A. Schulman's CEO was forced off the board, Ramius has indicated its intent to find a way for him to rejoin, though not as chairman or a voting member of the special committee formed to explore strategic alternatives. Gingo will become a nonvoting member of the strategic review committee, according to a Ramius spokesman. According to an Institutional Shareholder Services Inc. report issued Jan. 4, Ramius Capital suggested expanding the board by one member so he can maintain a seat.
The proxy contest followed the effort of another activist investor, James Mitarotonda's Barington Capital Group LP, who had launched proxy contests and settled with the company in the past. A. Schulman announced on Nov. 16 that it formed a committee to consider strategic alternatives such as a sale. A. Schulman also announced in November that chief executive Terry Haines was stepping down.

Wednesday, January 9, 2008

Activist Drilling with Warren Lichtenstein

Activist investor Warren Lichtenstein is seeing if he can drill some value out of Houston-based drilling services company Rowan Companies Inc., a company he has been publicly campaigning to achieve some change since July.

According to a Securities and Exchange Commission filing on Wednesday, Lichtenstein on Tuesday sent a letter to Rowan executives nominating three director candidates, including himself, for election to the company’s board.

Rowan has a $4.3 billion stock market capitalization. Steel Partners II LP, Lichtenstein's Aspen, Co.-based investment vehicle, has slowly been increasing its stake since publicly reporting an activist position on July 5. It reported owning a 9.1% Rowan stake on Wednesday. -- Ron Orol