Activist Investor Sun Capital Securities Group LLC is reaping the reward of its support from proxy advisory services firm Institutional Shareholder Services. Next stop, sale?
The insurgent investor on Thursday reported successfully winning three seats on the board of Furniture Brands International Inc. According to a proxy solicitor, Sun Capital won its three seats, for Alan Schwartz, Ira Kaplan and T. Scott King, by “a substantial margin.”
Their successful proxy contest comes after ISS last month recommended to it institutional investor clients that they should support the three-person dissident slate.
With directors on board, the activists may also be one step closer to buying the business. In addition to its proxy contest, the activist fund had made an unsolicited bid for the furniture maker on Feb. 21.
Furniture Brands shunned Sun Capital’s advances, saying that the strategic plan it launched in the fall of 2007 is “on track, and earnings momentum is developing.” A key part of that plan is to switch to an operating company model designed to generate $40 million to $50 million in annual cost savings.
The St. Louis, Mo.-based furniture-making company also points out that should Sun Capital win its contest to put its nominees on its board, these directors would have a conflict of interest because they would be "less likely to fight for value" once another bid was put on the table.
Nevertheless, Sun Capital’s vice president, Jason Bernzweig, was, unsurprisingly, excited by the result:
“The election of Sun Capital’s nominees is a victory for all Furniture Brands shareholders. Today’s results demonstrate shareholders’ desire for constructive change at Furniture Brands, and we are gratified by their support for our nominees. Our nominees look forward to working with the other Furniture Brands Board members, management and the Company’s talented employees to enhance performance and create long-term value for the benefit of all shareholders,” he said, in a statement. -- Ron Orol
Thursday, May 1, 2008
Sun Capital Wins Proxy Fight-- Next Up, a sale?
Wednesday, April 30, 2008
Icahn plus SWF = Time Warner cable division sale
A public activist effort that Carl Icahn began in 2005 and one that involved a sovereign wealth fund finally is coming to fruition.
That year Icahn began publicly pressing Time Warner Inc. chairman Richard Parsons to split up the media giant. On Wednesday, April 30, Time Warner Chief Executive Jeffrey L. Bewkes said the media giant would complete the spin off of Time Warner Cable, a divestiture Icahn had called for three years earlier.
In 2006, Icahn reluctantly backed down from his proposed proxy contest to press for a cable spin off and stock buyback. At the time he had the support of a number of activists including Jana Partners, SAC Capital Advisors LLC, and Franklin Mutual Advisers LLC. But they cumulatively had roughly a 3% stake in the company, not enough to move the institutional investors who backed Parsons.
A little known fact about Icahn’s efforts to break up Time Warner: He cooperated with a sovereign wealth fund in Dubai to press Time Warner to a sale.
According to a Feb 16, 2006 Schedule 13D filed by Istithmar PJSC, a Dubai based sovereign fund, its subsidiary, Istithmar Media Investments, which bought a 2.39% Time Warner stake, entered into a relationship with Icahn:
“In connection with [Istithmar Media Investments] acquisition of the Participation Notes and possible future investments in the Common Stock, [Istithmar] have retained Icahn Institutional Services LLC, an entity wholly owned by Mr. Carl Icahn, to serve as the investment advisor to [Istithmar Media Investments] with respect to [Istithmar Media Investments] economic exposure to shares of common stock through the participation notes and possible other investments in common stock.”
Istithmar PJSC is a Dubai-based firm that is owned by Dubai World, also the parent company of DP World, the Dubai owned company that sought unsuccessfully to acquire operations at six U.S. Ports. Lawmakers on Capitol Hill changed the law governing foreign acquisitions of U.S. assets after a U.S. government panel initially approved DP World's plans to acquire the six U.S. port operations. DP World backed down amid the resulting political uproar and agreed to sell its operations here to a U.S. entity.
Icahn’s Istithmar agreement was terminated shortly after it was formed, but it showed how in less politically charged days, a combination between an activist and a sovereign fund to press for changes at a U.S. company was not unthinkable. That kind of combination would raise the ire of lawmakers in Washington if it were to happen in today’s climate. -- Ron Orol
Friday, April 25, 2008
Activsts vs. Charming Shoppes: So Far, it looks like a Tie
A duo of activist investors seem to be having mixed luck with their efforts to press for changes at Charming Shoppes Inc., a Bensalem-based multi-brand retailer of women's plus-size apparel.
Hedge funds Crescendo Partners and Myca Partners have launched a proxy contest to install three director candidates on the company’s board at its May 8th scheduled annual meeting. But influential proxy advisory services company Glass Lewis & Co. only recommended one of the dissident duo’s slate, Michael Appel. The proxy advisory services company did not recommend institutional investors vote for Crescendo director Arnaud Ajdler and Myca official Robert Franfurt.
(A split recommendation is a favorite tool for the proxy advisory service firms in cases where they don’t want to appear too supportive of the dissidents or the management-backed incumbents)
Even so, Appel’s presence will likely help advance the share-value improvement goals of Crescendo and Myca. Appel’s experience as a retail-focused managing director at Quest Turnaround Advisors would likely bring a deal-oriented focus to Charming Shoppes. Though, company officials complain that his lack of experience as a director or in the apparel industry make him a bad candidate. Too bad for Charming Shoppes.
Also, largely in response to the activists, Charming Shoppes announced Friday it has retained Banc of America Securities and Lehman Brothers as financial advisors to assist the company in looking into “strategic alternatives” such as selling its “non-core misses apparel catalog titles in order to provide a greater focus on its core brands, Lane Bryant, Catherines and Fashion Bug, and to enhance shareholder value.”
That kind of restructuring is exactly the kind of thing activists are looking for. Even if Crescendo and Myca don’t get all three of their candidates on the company’s board, they can always come back next year with additional nominees. -- Ron Orol
Monday, April 21, 2008
Sun Capital's Furniture Brands Battle Heats Up
Activist investor Sun Capital Securities Group LLC may be one step closer its goal of putting three directors on the board of Furniture Brands International Inc. and, possibly, its goal of taking over the business.
The insurgent investor on Monday received the support of Institutional Shareholder Services, the influential investor proxy advisory firm, for all three of its candidates.
In addition to its proxy contest, the activist fund had made an unsolicited bid for the furniture-maker on Feb. 21.
Furniture Brands has shunned Sun Capital's advances, saying that the strategic plan it launched in the fall of 2007 is "on track, and earnings momentum is developing." A key part of that plan is to switch to an operating company model designed to generate $40 million to $50 million in annual cost savings.
The St. Louis, Mo.-based furniture-making company also points out that should Sun Capital win its contest to put its nominees on its board, these directors would have a conflict of interest because they would be "less likely to fight for value” once another bid was put on the table. -- Ron Orol
Thursday, April 17, 2008
New 13D Head at SEC
After five months without an official director, the Securities and Exchange Commission reportedly has a new head of mergers and acquisitions, Michele Anderson. And she's going to have her hands full.
The agency hasn't officially announced it yet, but Anderson was promoted to become the Corporate Finance division's new chief of the Office of M&A. Anderson replaces Brian Breheny, who in November moved up to become deputy director for Legal and Regulatory Policy at the agency.
High on Anderson's agenda will be figuring out what do about the agency's Schedule 13D rules when it comes to "cash-settled swap agreements" and other synthetic securities deals that activist hedge fund managers enter into with derivatives dealers. Do such swaps give activist hedge funds more control over a company's fate than they would like to let on? That's a question Anderson will try to figure out.
Recently, a railroad operator, CSX Corp., sued activist investor Children's Investment Fund Management LLP, charging that it violated federal securities laws by holding back information on how many shares it owned. Whether activist fund managers are forming illegal groups with derivatives dealers or just indirectly influencing the amount of shares being dumped on the market, Anderson's job will be a busy one.
In addition to 13Ds disclosure, Anderson will also be busy with cross-boarder business combination exemptions.
But Anderson comes prepared. Even though she worked recently as a legal branch chief in the Office of Telecommunications, she worked in the M&A office a few years earlier. - Ron Orol
Wednesday, April 16, 2008
Telos Wins Costa Brava Litigation
You win some and you lose some. Lately, hedge fund Costa Brava Partnerships III LP, has been on the losing end of their litigation activism approach.
Late Tuesday, April 15, the Circuit Court for Baltimore City dismissed a claim against information technology contractor Telos by the Boston-based hedge fund that the company was being managed for the benefit of insiders. The Costa Brava suit sought to have the court put Telos into receivership, wresting control away from existing management.
That loss piles up on a Jan. 7, Circuit Court of Baltimore City in Maryland order dismissing two claims against Telos by Costa Brava.
Costa Brava filed suit in 2005 claiming it was owed roughly $79 million in dividends.
Telos is privately owned, with 75% of its common stock owned by British investor, John Porter, while the rest is controlled by British investors, Telos management and employees. In 1989, the company issued publicly traded and redeemable preferred shares, some of which Costa Brava purchased, but the defense contractor didn’t pay dividends on the shares since their inception. In October 2005, shortly before a scheduled redemption date for the shares, a three-person committee of independent directors at Telos recommended that the company repurchase the entire package of preferred shares at what the panel considered a "substantial" discount.
One month later Costa Brava filed suit against the company and directors, arguing that it hadn't paid its obligations to preferred shareholders and that insiders were violating their fiduciary duty to investors. By August 2006 a special Telos litigation committee of six directors including two independent directors representing preferred holders, two Costa Brava representatives, set up by the company to investigate the matter, resigned.
Later, the company found other independent directors and set up a second special litigation committee that found that the counts against directors should be dismissed and that it was in the best interest of the company for the lawsuit to come to an end.
The Baltimore court in January concluded that the special litigation committee members "performed their duties in good faith" and "undertook a reasonable investigation" of Costa Brava's claims. The judge also dismissed claims against all directors, including Telos CEO John B. Wood. On April 15, the court also dismissed the activists other claims.
Costa Brava charged that when the ERPS was issued in 1989, Telos repeatedly stated in its Registration Statement to the SEC that the owners and prospective purchasers
of the ERPS should expect payment of [payment in kind] “PIK dividends in the first six years of the ERPS (1989-1995). But as part of the April 15 order: Judge Albert J. Matricciani, Jr. disagreed:
“…[I]n the judgment of the court neither the [Exchangeable Redeemable Preferred Stock] ERPS registration statement nor the company charter and Articles of Amendment and Restatement can be read to give rise to a contractual obligation with Telos to pay plaintiffs accrued [payment in kind] PIK dividends at the time of the first scheduled redemption date or anytime thereafter.”
The litigation activism approach wasn’t all bad news for Costa Brava. In a separate but related case, Costa Brava won a civil suit in Circuit Court of Fairfax County, Va., it launched in December 2005 against Telos' independent auditor, Goodman & Co (there were no damages awarded). The activist hedge fund alleged in the suit that Telos hire Goodman to produce an audit that would help it avoid redeeming millions of dollars of preferred stock of the IT firm owned by Costa Brava and other investors. Later, Goodman & Co. filed an appeal motion after the trial and on March 25, the Fairfax County judge reaffirmed the jury’s verdict.
Judge Bellows’ ruling of March 25: “As to sufficiency, the Court finds that there was sufficient evidence to support the jury’s verdict [that Goodman & Company aided and abetted a breach of fiduciary duty by Telos and its Directors].” Not introduced in the Fairfax case was a February letter from the SEC giving Telos a clean bill of health, accounting wise. -- Ron Orol
Saturday, April 12, 2008
Did blogger Jackson help Icahn?
Two months after Carl Icahn failed to have his nominee elected in a proxy contest at Motorola Inc. in 2007, YouTube video blogger Eric Jackson jumped into the fray. His activism strategy used a YouTube video he dubbed "Plan B for Motorola" and an Internet Wiki to attract support from other micro-investors like himself. Like Icahn, Jackson wanted Motorola CEO Ed Zander gone, much of the board replaced and a new head of Mobile Devices with a clear strategy.
When the company revealed major financial problems in its second quarter 2007 financials two days later, Jackson says his effort began receiving major support. He got the backing of roughly 150 investors with about $600,000 in shares, less than 1% but significant nonetheless.
"They didn't move quickly enough, so starting late last year, we started saying that the best course of action, given the extent of the problems in the company, was to break it up," Jackson says.
And while Icahn's two-year public prodding is certainly the major reason why Motorola decided Wednesday it will split into two independent, publicly traded companies, Jackson's novel approach to activism is lifting eyebrows. Anne Faulk, chief executive of Swingvote Inc. in Atlanta, says Jackson may be the vanguard of how shareholders and executives communicate with each other. Certainly, some of Jackson's goals -- having Motorola executive Ed Zander resign and seeing that the company divide into two units -- have been accomplished.
The same can be said of Jackson's efforts last year at his first YouTube activist campaign at Yahoo! Inc., which also has gone through serious changes since his insurgency began. Jackson sent out a "Yahoo! Plan B" YouTube video and later launched a "just vote no" campaign to persuade shareholders of the widely used Santa Clara, Calif.-based portal to expel its CEO, Terry Semel, from his chairmanship along with six others on the company's 10-person board. He also set up a blog, "Breakout Performance," a MySpace.com account and a LinkedIn Web site to spread dissent.
Semel later did resign, and now Microsoft Corp. has a $31 a share, or $44.6 billion offer on the table.
With the stock of Motorola still low at around $10 a share, don't expect Jackson to end his insurgency just yet. In February Jackson launched a $2 million activist fund, Ironfire Capital LLC. Even with few dollars behind him, corporations should beware of Jackson's YouTube "Plan B." - Ron Orol