Thursday, January 31, 2008

Emancipating Captaris?

Information delivery services company Captaris Inc. is probably not that excited about the information that was delivered to them by Emancipation Capital LP on Thursday.

The New York-based activist fund reported in a Securities and Exchange Commission filing that the company should form an independent committee to explore “strategic alternatives,” to improve share value. Those are often code words that mean: find a buyer or issue a special dividend.

“In the ordinary course of their investment business, from time to time, representatives of [Emancipation Capital] engage in discussions with the management of companies in which they have invested concerning the business and operations of such companies and
potential approaches to maximizing shareholder value,” the activists wrote in a filing.

Emancipation Capital reported owning a 5.1% stake in Captaris, which has a $91 million stock market capitalization. In addition to information delivery services, Captaris manages documents electronically and develops software products. -- Ron Orol

Wednesday, January 30, 2008

Seidman to Massbank: Learn Who You Are Dealing With

Thrift-specialist, activist hedge fund manager Lawrence Seidman wants Massbank Corp.’s President and chief executive to know exactly who he is.

Seidman, who has engaged management and launched successful proxy contests at several thrifts through his Seidman and Associates LLC fund, wrote a letter Wednesday to Massbank CEO Gerard H. Brandi explaining that the two should have a conversation about his past endeavors.

In late December, Seidman launched a proxy contest to nominate three candidates, including himself, to the company board.

According to a letter attached to a Securities and Exchange Commission filing on Wednesday, Seidman said he was under the impression that Brandi wanted to investigate his previous activist efforts. In response, Seidman wrote that Brandi simply should give him a call and he would receive the names of directors of all the boards he has served on.

“Since you have a desire to investigate me, if you or your counsel contact me, I will provide you with the names of directors at every financial institution where I was a member of the Board, or had a representative on the Board, so you can contact these individuals, who have direct knowledge about me and my interaction with other financial institutions,” Seidman wrote.

And Seidman appears to be angling for some sort of settlement with Massbank. In the letter he points out that “nobody profits from a proxy contest other than the consultants.” Perhaps Massbank will take Seidman up on his offer and strike a deal to put him on the board. In exchange, perhaps Seidman would drop his proxy contest.

Reading, Mass-based Massbank has a $154 million stock market capitalization. Seidman and Associates holds a 7.4% Massbank stake. -- Ron Orol

Ron Orol is a Washington-based reporter for The Deal and author of Extreme Value Hedging: How Activist Hedge Fund Managers Are Taking on the World.

Tuesday, January 29, 2008

Fashion Activism with Barington Capital vs. Dillards

Jim Mitarotonda is staying true to form with a new activist campaign launched at Dillard’s Inc., a large fashion apparel and home furnishings retailer.

Mitarotonda’s Barington Capital Group LP and another activist investor, Clinton Group, reported in a government regulatory filing that they own 5.3% of Little Rock, Ark.-based Dillards, and they are recommending operational and strategic improvements, such as eliminating its duel-class stock structure, evaluating its senior management team and shuffling the company’s real estate portfolio by closing underperforming properties.

Barington’s effort at Dillard’s follows up on the activist’s campaigns at other fashion apparel companies, including Syms Corp., Payless Shoes and Speedo swimwear and Calivin Klein under and jeans maker Warnaco Group Inc. For Mitarotonda, who got his start in the New York fashion scene with a job at fashion trendsetter Bloomingdale's in New York in the early 1980s, fashion activism is par for the course.

The activist funds also would like to see the company complete a sale-lease back of owned properties, a typical tactic considered by activist investors seeking to have corporations raise capital for other purposes such as stock buybacks or special dividends.

Barington and his group sent two letters to Dillard’s board, in August and a follow up letter on Jan. 29, according to the filing. “The disappointing financial performance of Dillard’s must be addressed,” Barington wrote. “While we acknowledge that the market conditions in the department store sector have been challenging over the past few quarters due to concerns with a weakening U.S. economy, the magnitude of Dillard’s recent weak results cannot be attributed to the economy alone.”

The activist group says in the filing that it is “committed to taking all actions necessary,” which for Barington, in the past, has at times included launching proxy contests to replace directors.

Barington and Clinton Group have launched activist efforts at the same company in the past. After Barington launched an insurgency at Steven Madden Ltd., Clinton Group followed up with its own activist effort there. -- Ron Orol


Ron Orol is a Washington-based reporter for The Deal and author of Extreme Value Hedging: How Activist Hedge Fund Managers Are Taking on the World.

Tuesday, January 22, 2008

Syms: To Go Private or Not to Go Private

Two activist investors on Tuesday stepped up their campaign to have Syms Corp., a New York discount clothing retailer, reconsider its decision to delist from the New York Stock Exchange. According to a statement, Barington Capital Group and Esopus Creek Advisors, who together own 9.8% of Syms, filed a lawsuit in the Superior Court of the State of New Jersey, alleging that Syms directors broke their fiduciary duty to investors by enabling the company to delist. The activist group also is demanding a copy of the company’s shareholder list.

Syms delisted from the NYSE on Jan. 14 and is seeking to deregister its shares on April 1. Barington Capital Group and Esopus Creek Advisors sent a letter to Syms’ board earlier this month expressing their displeasure with the company’s decision to deregister. “The group believes that such actions will destroy shareholder value,” Barington and Esopus Creek wrote in the letter that was attached to a Schedule 13D filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission.
In its statement, Syms argues that investors will be able to buy and sell stock on the pink sheets, maintaining a sufficient level of liquidity and the deregistration will save the company $750,000. "The company estimates that the savings in both direct and indirect costs associated with deregistration will be substantial on an ongoing basis and that the direct recurring annual savings will exceed $750,000," Syms wrote in a Dec. 21 press release. "The company also expects that management will be able to better focus its attention and resources on continuing to improve operations and enhancing shareholder value."
But investors following the company contend that the real reason why Syms wants to deregister is to lower the value of the stock price so that management, including store founder Sy Sims, 81, could complete a management-led buyout at an inexpensive valuation leaving shareholders with lost value.
"It appears that the Syms family does not believe that their company's motto 'An educated consumer is our best customer' should apply to its investors as well," stated a large investor that requested anonymity. - Ron Orol

Ron Orol is a Washington-based reporter for The Deal and author of Extreme Value Hedging: How Activist Hedge Fund Managers Are Taking on the World.

Saturday, January 19, 2008

Borders AND Ackman Get Together

Major activist investor Bill Ackman (pictured at left) and bookseller Borders Group Inc. have reached a compromise--for now. On Friday, the Ann Arbor, Mich.-based bookstore chain named Richard McGuire, a partner in Ackman's activist fund, Pershing Square Capital Management LP, to its board. Pershing Square has an 18% Borders stake.
Ackman's public campaign at Borders launched in 2006, when Ackman expressed at an investor conference that the company' stock price could be higher. But Pershing Square really launched its campaign when Ackman in October expressed in an SEC filing that he could consider electing a slate of directors. In the filing, Ackman indicated that he wants to shake up the executive suites and to tinker with the company's restructuring plan. At the time, he held an 11.7% stake.
Borders isn't the only retailer currently in Ackman's sites. Discount retailer Target is also facing an activist push from Pershing, but so far Ackman hasn't threatened to elect a slate of directors. Instead, he reportedly is pushing for sales of Target's credit card business and real estate. - Ron Orol

Cnet Vs. Jana Partners

In "A Loophole Lets a Foot in the Door" (Jan. 15), the New York Times' Andrew Ross Sorkin describes how CNET chief executive Neil Ashe had an hour-long conversation with activist investors at Jana Partners. According to the column, Ashe was then surprised when Jana and its group launched a proxy contest to take over the board. "They indicated to us that they were a long-only deep-value hedge fund," Ashe says, according to Sorkin. "I spent an hour with them on the phone answering questions about our business." Then, he adds: "We didn't hear anything from them again."
Sorkin uses this anecdote to explain how activist fund managers use "complex swap agreements with investment banks" to get around disclosure rules and launch surprise attacks. Is this the whole story, however? Maybe not. Regulatory filings disclose that prior to Sorkin's column, Jana Partners and its group held talks with CNET officials indicating that their activist campaign really should not have been any surprise to Ashe and probably wasn't.
In a 13D filing disclosed Jan 7, a week before Sorkin's column, Jana reported that representatives had held several calls with CNET through October, at least one of which was to discuss proposals for improving operations. The filing also says that Spark Management Partners LLC's Santo Politi, a venture capitalist and member of the Jana group, met on Dec. 6 with CNET chairman Jarl Mohn to inform him of the investment by the group, "to discuss proposals for improving the operating performance" and to request a follow-up meeting with independent board members; Ashe rejected the latter. "In a subsequent conversation, Mohn informed Politi that any discussions with members of the board would need to be coordinated by Ashe," the filing said.
Soon after, on Dec. 28, Jana delivered notice to CNET that it planned to nominate directors. These conversations demonstrate that Jana and its group actually had talks with CNET officials and aired their proposals. They also suggest that Jana didn't think everything was fine with the business. Ashe's decision to reject a meeting between CNET independent board members and the Jana group also shows that the situation wasn't exactly "friendly."
And let's get real. We're talking about Jana Partners here, a major activist hedge fund that regularly launches campaigns, not some obscure fund from under a rock. Sorkin gives the impression that Ashe was "surprised" because Jana had talked about becoming a "friendly, long-term shareholder." Any IR official or corporate executive with a heartbeat would know that Jana will launch an activist campaign if it doesn't get its way.
The issue of swaps is a matter for continuing debate, but one thing is clear from the filings: Ashe and his team were either not surprised, or shouldn't have been. - Ron Orol

Thursday, January 17, 2008

CtW calls out Merrill Lynch directors

An organization that advises pensions for unions belonging to the Change to Win labor group has a new target: Merrill Lynch & Co.

The pension fund, CtW Investment Group, is calling on Merrill Lynch directors to "describe what they did to protect shareholders from excessive mortgage-related risk over the past two years."
The fund said in a statement that it plans to launch a "just vote no" campaign against Merrill Lynch's nomination committee chairwoman, should the investment bank not provide a thoughtful response to its question. (CtW would have preferred to consider urging investors to oppose members of the finance committee, but none of these members are up for election this year.)
The investment fund earlier this week took similar actions against five directors at Citigroup Inc., another bank besieged with mortgage-related problems.
Both Citigroup and Merrill Lynch have recently been the recipients of massive cash infusions (read: bailouts) from controversial state-controlled sovereign wealth funds. In December, Temasek Holdings Pte. Ltd. took a $4.4 billion minority stake in Merrill Lynch. Abu Dhabi Investment Authority reported a $7.5 billion minority stake investment in Citigroup in November. - Ron Orol

Ron Orol is a Washington-based reporter for The Deal and author of Extreme Value Hedging: How Activist Hedge Fund Managers Are Taking on the World.